Youngs, Benjamin Franklin
- Township: Embro & West Zorra
- Rank: Corporal
- Branch: First Michigan Volunteer Sharpshooters
- Date of birth: June 27, 1844
- Where born: West Zorra Township, Oxford County, Ontario, Canada
- Date of death: January 14, 1927
- Burial location: Odd Fellows Cemetery, 3640 Whittier Blvd, Los Angeles, California
- Wars Served: American Civil War
- Years of service: 1863 - 1864
- Country enlisted with: United States
Benjamin Franklin Youngs was born on June 27, 1844 in Brooksdale, Oxford County, Ontario. He was the second son of Lanty Shannon Youngs and Sophronia Taft. In the USA Civil War was breaking out and like many from Canada with United Empire Loyalist ties, Benjamin went to the USA and enlisted with the First Michigan Volunteer Sharpshooters. On June 17, 1864 at Petersburg, Virginia he captured the enemy flag and for this earned the Medal of Honour. He served in the American Civil War from 1863 to 1864.
After returning home to Brooksdale Benjamin married Margaret Reid and they would raise five sons and a daughter. Initially they lived in Brooksdale but later moved to Stratford. Benjamin was a carpenter by trade and built many buildings throughout the area. One such building that exists today is St. Andrews United Church in Brooksdale built in 1883. In Stratford he served as an Alderman from 1892 to 1896.
Benjamin returned to the USA sometime after 1896. He died at the Old Soldiers Nursing Home in Los Angeles, California on January 14, 1927. He and his wife Margaret are buried in the Odd Fellows Cemetery, Los Angeles, California.
The following was written by Bart Armstrong, Victoria, BC and read at the memorial unveiling in Los Angeles, California May 2010:
Most Canadians, and indeed all North Americans have probably never heard of the little hamlet called Youngsville in what was then called Canada West (Ontario). Located in the Township of Zorra, within Oxford County this community was settled by strong, community-minded United Empire Loyalists and ancestors to many who are honoured to join with you today.
Youngsville was founded in 1830 when approximately 1000 acres of land at a crossroads were purchased by Gabriel Youngs and cleared and settled by many of his sons. This land would soon house a hotel that would, for a period host the local council meetings and a post office. On this land were soon built a cider mill, blacksmith shop, carriage-works and many dwellings. Later a school would be built on these same lands. It and the hotel would stand for over 100 years.
Gabriel & Amelia Youngs would raise four sons and three daughters. One of the sons (Lanty Shannon Youngs) would himself raise five boys and two girls. And one of these boys was a fellow named Benjamin Franklin Youngs. (BF)
Benjamin, named after his great grandfather, would be born and raised on a farm just a few miles north of Youngsville in a community called Brooksdale. In youth, he found work as a carpenter.
In either 1862 or 1863 BF was possibly living in the Dearbonville area of Michigan State (now known as Dearborn). On September 1, 1863 the 19 yr old teenager had done what some 50,000 other Canadians had done. He had signed up for service in the Civil War by joining the army with an enlistment at Detroit, about 7 miles east of Dearbonville. Within days he was mustered into the First Michigan Volunteer Sharpshooters, a perfect fit as the teen was a known crackshot back on the family farm. He’d get a $25 bounty for enrolling.
Ten days before his next birthday, and within 10 months of enlistment, Benjamin Franklin Youngs would become an American war hero.
But much less dramatic, his army service would start out with the Sharpshooters playing the roll of guards at Camp Douglas located in Chicago. Part of the 80 acre complex would in later days become home for the first location of the University of Chicago. Condominiums sit on part of the site today.
The Camp would first house about 7,000 Confederate POW’s from Fort Donelson in February of 1862. (A Medal of Honor would be issued to a Northern sailor for action at Donelson, and who would later live and raise a family at Halifax, Nova Scotia for over 3 decades.) Before being closed down the camp would have housed over 20,000 POW’s, as much as 12,000 at one point.
Camp Douglas would eventually become known as the “Andersonville of the North” for it’s inhumane conditions and would see the deaths of over 1,500 before being closed down.
It appears that the first 8 months of BF’s short 13 month Civil War career was spent guarding at Camp Douglas. After just three months he was promoted to Corporal. One hopes it was not for the type of treatment it seems was a daily event at this horrible camp.
Comparing portions of his archived service records to the Sharpshooters history reveals that Corporal Benjamin Franklin Youngs was probably present during the battles at The Wilderness, New York and Po Rivers and at Spotsylvania, all in Virginia, and the last being where he received the first of at least two.. if not three wounds.
Hospitalized for 6 days, BF would then return to his unit and probably the battles at North Anna, Totopotomoy Creek, Bethesda Church and Cold Harbor, still all within the state of Virginia.
He and his unit then participated on the advance on Richmond and the engagement of several skirmishes or battles en-route in the Petersburg Campaign. It would be here at an assault on the Confederate works that Corporal Youngs would capture the colors of the 35th North Carolina Infantry, Confederate States of America.
When the unit drove back the Confederate unit into its entrenchment, Youngs jumped into the trench and seized the colors. These were immediately carried back to friendly lines and Youngs escorted the colors with others who escorted many POW’s back to the Head Qquarters of the next higher authority, that of the 9th Corps, Army of the Potomac, where all were presented to the general in charge. In reward for gallantry in the field and capturing the enemy’s flag, the General promoted Youngs on the spot to the rank of Sergeant. His name was also forwarded up the line and cited for gallantry and no doubt the Medal of Honor.
Years later the story became accepted that Youngs did not capture the flag, but was in fact ordered by his Captain to seize it from the enemy after a Private in the regiment had pointed a bayonet to the Southerner’s throat. The Captain was then himself injured and spent weeks elsewhere recovering. Upon return to the regiment the officer became quite upset at learning of the Youngs promotion and recommendation for the Medal of Honor. He was so infuriated at Youngs who apparently gave no credit whatsoever to the Private, that the Captain demoted him back to Corporal. The demotion was overruled when the matter was brought before the general.
Letters written by the Captain some 15 years later and to higher authorities continued to advance the Captain’s views that Youngs did not deserve the medal. Many decades later these letters would resurface when being quoted by the author in a very detailed history of the First Michigan Sharpshooters Volunteer Infantry Regiment.
However, a completely different view is painted by one affidavit and several sworn testimonials taken, under oath and in writing, made just days after the event. Documents held by the US National Archives. Several privates, two Lieutenants and a Captain all provided evidence to higher authority that it was indeed Youngs who captured the flag. These testimonials gave no mention whatsoever of a private holding a bayonet to the Southerners throat, nor evidence to the Captain being on the spot, let alone ordering Youngs into action.
Unfortunately, these letters nor their content are not widely circulated. Thus, the apparent erroneous claims made of Youngs lack of a qualification for the medal, are all that most learn about the matter.
Within days of the Petersburg flag capturing, Youngs found himself in hospital recuperating from another wound.
A month later it is believed that Youngs participated in the horrific slaughter on both sides at the Battle of the Crater.
After several attempts at the Union’s making headway and being pushed back, one of the regiments had an interesting idea. Why not dig a tunnel under the enemy fort and just blow it up? The unit, consisting of miners in pre war days, was given the go ahead and for several weeks dug forward over 500 ft, and then to left and right about another 75”, all being about 50’ below ground level. Then about 8,000 pounds of gunpowder were placed at the centre of the T structure and at both ends. Each of the 3 points being below heavy enemy gun positions directly above.
About 350 Confederates were killed within seconds when the mine was blown. The thunder was felt in the Confederate capital of Richmond. By days end over 5,000 men would either have been killed, wounded, missing in action or taken prisoner of war. Enemy losses were less than the Union for several reasons. After the explosion a massive crater was formed, still in existence today. It measured about 170 “ by 80” and about 30’ deep. Battle plans were changed at the last moment and untrained troops were the first ordered into the pit, with many units following. None were told what to do once they got there. It didn’t help much that the commander.. a general… was off getting drunk when the mine was blown. Mass confusion followed.
Making matters worse, the walls of the crater became so unstable that the men could not climb out. The Confederates were quick to bring up reinforcements and take advantage of the situation. They simply took positions along part of the edge, then took their shots at the Union soldiers, sitting ducks that they were.
General Grant, a future US President, was in the area and later stated…”It was the saddest affair I have witnessed in this war.”
The records show that Youngs was with his unit at this time and so it is assumed that he was also in the midst of this catastrophe. He also fought during the Battle of Weldon Railroad just a few weeks later and would be listed there as missing in action. It was later realized that he had been captured and became a POW.
He would be held by the Confederates at Richmond, then Varina Va and finally at Camp Parole at Annapolis Maryland. On either 4 or 20 Oct 1864 BF was released from Confederate hands, given a 20 day furlough and sent on his way home to either Michigan, per his personnel file, or possibly back to Brooksdale Ontario where he still had family. (A few miles north of Youngsville).
He never returned to service, and on 15 November 1864 was listed on the Sharpshooters company rolls as being a deserter.
Most curiously, one of the documents in a file held by the descendants of BF is a letter dated Nov. 23, 1864. It is a letter from the War Department and initialled by the sender with the initials E.D.T. and titled Assistant Adjutant General. At the time the position was occupied by Edward David Townsend, the very man playing a critical role in the creation of the Medal in the early days of the war. The letter announced that a Medal of Honor had been awarded, and that the recipient ought to find it enclosed with the request that it’s receipt be acknowledged.
This is curious since only weeks earlier BF Youngs was listed as being a deserter and deserters in those days were not given the Medal of Honor. If so awarded, they were later rescinded.
Recognized MOH research resources also note in some cases that the date of awarding of the medal to Youngs is unknown. Others list a date of December 1 1864. Yet this document seems to suggest, by its wording, that Youngs had already been communicated with about the award, and reasons thereof, and that this letter was simply a letter of transmission of the medal with acknowledgement requested. Thus the date of the award would have been even earlier than 23 November 1864.
As this letter was un-addressed, it is unknown if the medal was sent to him at Michigan or in Canada.
By 1871 the Ontario census covering the West Zorra area had listed Benjamin, now back in home territory, married and living with two children ages 2 and 1. BF’s family would grow to 6 boys and 2 girls by 1879, with one appearing to have died in infancy. Benjamin was listed as being in the house carpentry business and his sons followed in his footsteps, one going on to actually building the city hall at Stratford Ont.
While one daughter still lived with her mother in Ontario in 1901, a US census for the area of Brockway, Saint Clair County Michigan had BF listed as being a carpenter living on a farm in the area. The record also showed that he had by then been living in the US since 1897. By 1913 it is believed that he was living in La. California close to either a brother or son, both named Theodore.
The Sharpshooter history book states that Youngs had received his Medal of Honor in 1913, and had commented that not only was…”it a beauty”, but that…”I am proud of it.”
In as much as family descendants today have two Medals of Honor inscribed to BF, it seems obvious that an earlier one was already issued... perhaps back in 1864 as the earlier document suggested. One of the two medals is clearly the Civil War model of army Medal. A second would have been presented when the Gillespie model of the medal was created and issued in 1896. Perhaps it was this later model that he received in 1913.
A picture of BF and wife Margaret, held by the family and mislabelled as being taken in the late 1920’s ( both died in 1927), shows Benjamin wearing what appears to be the Grand Army of the republic membership medal. Upon very close inspection of an enlarged copy of the picture, it appears that BF may also be wearing his CW type of Medal of Honor around his neck.
On March 4 1925 the US Congress passed an…”Act For the Relief of Benjamin F. Youngs.” In this legislation the Congress acknowledged BF’s rank as a Sergeant and that he was from that day forth to be documented as having been released honorably. The Congress also noted his entitled from then on to any benefits other honorably released soldiers enjoyed.
Days later BF applied for an Invalid Pension with application #1517312 and it was granted with certificate #1268089 on April 7 of that year. Shortly after his death in 1927, his wife Margaret applied for a Widow’s Pension with application #1573041 and it was soon granted with certificate #102228, but she also was to soon die, and before the year was out was buried beside her husband, a son Theodore, and in 1953 the three would be joined by a second son Arthur. All being buried in a family plot at Odd Fellows Cemetery at Los Angeles.
Benjamin’s first Medal of Honor was issued with the surname Young instead of Youngs. The second (replacement) medal was issued with the correct spelling. Unfortunately today’s MOH reference materials often still list him under the misspelled name.